Friday, August 12, 2005

The Connection Between Creativity and Mental Illness

This is excerpted from a paper I wrote while attending graduate school in Chico, CA. I thought it might be helpful to the artist out there who wants to know more about the connection between depression (and other mental illnesses) and creativity. If the findings are correct, and the "mentally ill" have so much to offer, then what does this say about the treatment of this segment of society?

Consciousness, introspection, self-awareness, and abstract thinking have no basis in scientific measurement (Swerdlow, 1995). Science, however, seems to be heading in this direction. Humans have this need for explanation, and as such, we have discovered that the planum temporale in the left hemisphere, a part of the brain associated with auditory processing, is larger in musicians than in non-musicians, and is larger still in musicians with perfect pitch. Other research indicates that van Gogh may have suffered from temporal lobe epilepsy, which triggered electrical hyperactivity of the brain (Swerdlow, 1995).

There are more recent cases which point to physiology as it effects the creative process. By the 1950’s, Howard Hughes had established himself as a filmmaker, inventor, designer, engineer, industrialist and businessman. By the 1970’s, he was said to be one of the most eccentric people in America, living in isolation, giving out strict orders to his staff on how to maintain cleanliness, once test landing a plane some five thousand times when only twenty or so was necessary, and generally living out a life of extraordinarily bizarre behaviors. Yet, no one questioned this, intervened or even insisted that he get help!! Why? Perhaps, they thought this was common for a creative genius, man of his caliber, or normal for the rich and famous to act peculiar. What we know now is that Howard Hughes was suffering from obsessive compulsive disorder (Osborne, 1998). PET scans reveal that the brain of someone suffering from obsessive compulsive disorder is overactive, particularly the section known as the caudate nucleus. The entire frontal cortex of a person with this condition literally lights up when compared to a person without the condition. The mental activity that made Hughes a great genius, was also slowly killing him.

What I have learned in my study of this disorder is that what makes some people crazy, can also make them creative, or great if they choose. Winston Churchill and Martin Luther, both great leaders in their time, suffered the effects of mental illness. Churchill had terrible depression and Martin Luther, though it wasn’t called this at the time, had obsessive compulsive disorder. Martin Luther was said to be scrupulous, literally asking for forgiveness more than twenty times a day for acts committed that day (Jamision, 1995). There is an endless list of people that I have read or heard about that suffered from mental illness and were also creative. Is there a connection?

It would be hard to imagine that there is not. The brain is acting in such a way as to stimulate thought, insight, imagination, excitement and emotion. What we do not manifest into some creative outlet is likely to take its toll in another equally profound way. A few years ago, I had a conversation with a doctor concerning his son and his son’s outrageous, counter productive behavior in my classroom. When we discussed the possible reasons, his answer was that his son acted this way, not because he meant any harm or disrespect, but because “his brain required it.” Acting out, creating, being weird, whatever we wish to call it is really the brain’s way of achieving the balance it needs.

Edward O. Wilson, in Consilience, discusses this very notion on the section involving dreaming. He reports that in a dream state, the person is really insane. What he means is that these images, thoughts, impulses, if occurring during a cognizant, awake state would classify any of us as insane. What is going on during one of these states is interesting. The amines that the brain normally produces – such as norepinephrine and serotonin run low. Wilson suggests that the brain, in a dream state, is compensating for low levels of these chemicals by producing fantastic images. Take this a step further and one can see why artists and creative people tend to be so depressed. They too are compensating. They want so badly to get out of this state and the only option is a creation of their own doing, something so amazing that it literally alters their brain chemistry! It would naturally follow that the deeper one feels depression the more creative they are apt to be. The "normal" nine-to-five crowd, to some, is uninspiring and unimaginative. Well, they don’t need to be. Their brains do not require it.

Julia Cameron (1992), in the Artist’s way, confirms this, though in a less scientific way. She says, that our brightest ideas are often “proceeded by a gestation period that is inferior, murky, and completely necessary.” People seeking to reach that perfect state of creativity toy with these brain levels, trying to find the perfect amount of sadness or joy or whatever emotion will propel their project to great heights of pure creativity. When such levels are insufficient, they turn to exercise, thrill seeking, or worse, coffee, tobacco, alcohol and worse yet, drugs. It is really a never ending battle for the perfect state of being, and the perfect state of creative contribution.

Spalding Gray (1985) writes about this in his cult classic, Swimming to Cambodia. As an actor in the movie The Killing Fields, he swore not to leave Thailand until he had achieved what he called the “perfect moment.” To paraphrase, the perfect moment was to him, that moment when everything came together, producing an amazing experience (Gray, 1985). This was the experience that one would remember most, the experience that would define the journey, the one to tell family and friends about. For Michael Jordan, it was important to leave basketball at the peak of his game, probably in a moment not too different from what Gray was writing about. Jordan, was in effect, the writer of the play on his life. As director, why not make it dramatic, thrilling, emotional, or even perfect?

Does this have implications for education? Without a doubt it does. Here we are, teachers directing students, literally taking away their control, their ability to form personal meaning and imposing, almost forcing content down their throats. Yet, we somehow expect them to learn from this?! Eric Jensen’s (1998) research in Teaching with the Brain in Mind would probably caution against this, noting that “emotion helps reason to focus the mind and set priorities. Many researchers now believe that emotion and reason are not opposites. For example, our logical side says, ‘set a goal.’ But only our emotions get us passionate enough even to care enough to act on that goal.” (Daniel Goleman, 1995) argues that emotions are equally important to basic logic when making a decision. Perhaps the answer to this is to allow the students more control in decision making, in personal choice making, not just at home but at school.

12 comments:

rah said...

LEE
Firstly, I love the POLLOCK PIC!!!
Secondly, this discussion is so RIGHT ON!!! I'd love to read more!
RAH

Anonymous said...

finally!!!!!

A.B. said...

Dear Mr Chazen, I enjoyed your though-provoking post. I think that in our pharmacuetically obsessed society, there is denial of natural human sadness --- and that perhaps depression need not be
a "disease" but may be indeed about growth. I am now reading "Where The Roots Reach for Water"(North Point Press) by Jeffery Smith and I highly recommend it. And keep up the good work!

Anonymous said...

I Think that you are absolutely right. We have all experienced the unsatisfaction of ourself untill we have created something we can take pride in. I believe I suffer (if you would like to call it that), with what you are describing. Some times bein frustrated or anxious for no appearent reason, (obvously some type of disorder) I could be kept up all night even if im tired, only being able to sooth myself by pulling out the keyboard and record a melody of expression. Its like im creating my own remidy to relief my symptoms, thus creating a beautifull piece of expressive art, driven by my own mental disability.

Balhatain said...

I write for the Myartspace Blog and I just posted an entry concerning the link between mental illness and creativity. I've also been discussing the stereotypes concerning artists lately. It would be great to read your opinion on the topic.

www.myartspace.com/blog

Anonymous said...

Mr. Chazen,
My wife sent me a reference to this blog as it has related to many discussions that she and I have had during the course of our marriage (a wondrous condition that has lasted now a mere five years, and hopefully is blessed with another fifty or more to go). And, after reading the post several times, was inclined to post a comment - a rare moment of weakness indeed! :-)

I found this blog to be quite unsatisfying. Why, might you ask? Because it leaves one wanting much, much more.

I am fascinated with the whole concept of "not being in your right mind", a comment made about many with so-called mental abnormalities. Not being in your 'right mind' refers to a condition that you describe quite well in your post. Anyone that doesn't adhere to societies 'norm' - logic based and entirely 'right-minded' - is deemed to have socially unacceptable mores.

As you have pointed out, most of human history's most prolific creators do/have live(d) mostly in their 'left-mind' and so, would be deemed mentally disturbed by today's standards.

Those among us who [have/do] live equally in both our right- and left-minds also are plagued by not "fitting in."

I myself am both artist and engineer. I paint, write poetry and fiction, play guitar, and otherwise entertain myself and others with my left-minded approach to thinking and life. I am also a designer, writer, and technical engineer; what I 'do' for a living.

I wish that more people would look at individuals for their contribution, not for their conformance. If one looks at the changes that have occurred, and seem to be occurring much more rapidly, in today's society, one would see that our right-minded life - thoroughly ensconced and enveloped with the technology of everyday life as it is - drives more people to rage at the restriction such life forces on the id. Is it any wonder that the past several generations, and specifically todays's youth, should be 'angered' and left feeling abandoned by the 'norms' imposed by society.

Should we delve deeper into certain psychoses, bipolar disorder, ADHD, and autism to name a few - we might find that encouraging those who suffer these 'psychoses' to delve further into their left-minredness might well result in a normalizing of the right-minded thinking.

Even with all of our technilogical advances, we cannot, not should we, weed out those of us who are not in our 'right mind.'

Crispen Scott
'full-minded' thinker

Anonymous said...

Mental illness is a neurological No-Fault Brain Disease. The symptoms usually present themselves between the ages of 16 and 25. When we speak of mental illness we usually refer to schizophrenia, manic depression or bi- polar disorder, severe depression, obsessive compulsive disorder, and panic anxiety attacks. http://www.xanax-effects.com/

xanax said...

Anxiety disorder is considered to be one of the worst mental conditions that affect human beings by making them prone to baseless and groundless worries but with the arrival of anti-anxiety medications like xanax in the pharmaceutical market, successful treatment of anxiety related disorders has become an instant possibility. But, instead of straightway moving ahead to use Xanax and other medicines to treat anxiety such as Buspar and Tenormin, you can log in to http://www.pill-care.com and get hold of fundamental tidbits on these medicines first.

Anonymous said...

Let's talk about mental and emotional related defects, prevalent in many families especially those of professionals and intellectuals who live under high pressures to succeed greatly. Many intelligent, high achieving, individuals suffer from anxieties, schizophrenias and depression. Obsessive-compulsive disorder comes very closely related. http://www.buy-xanax-online-now.com/

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Your right brain is your soul, left is your mind. It is true that Americans souls are snatched from them as youths. As people develop or reconnect to their soul through experiences they begin to feel. The result of having feelings in America is called mental illness and now they are trying to sell it as a permanent genetic disease. Mental illness is having a soul in a world of soulless , ego driven left brain ignoramuses who can only argue or reason, but cannot think for themselves. The greatest thinkers are being driven into madness by the greedy and ambitious society we live in. You have no idea of the true human potential, because you are trained to believe you are only meant to be "workers".

seller said...

very gooddoutif